JOSHUA TREE, San Bernardino County — November 12, 2026. A 64-lot housing development on Alta Loma Drive has been approved again by county supervisors after a judge ordered officials to revisit environmental review deficiencies. The decision came despite strong objections from Joshua Tree residents who question how a shared wastewater plant and stormwater basin would work on a small common parcel above the groundwater used for drinking.
Residents explained why the revised study still worries them
At the November 3 San Bernardino County Board of Supervisors hearing, Melissa Spurr challenged the way county staff characterized a letter from the Colorado River Basin Regional Water Quality Control Board. She said the board's position and the staff's description could not both fully capture the unresolved requirements for the proposed treatment plant. Erin Gatlin, a vice president of the Morongo Basin Conservation Association, argued that the half-acre common parcel would have to accommodate a package treatment plant, seepage and expansion pits, utilities and a stormwater detention basin.
According to the Desert Trumpet's detailed review of the county video and documents, Joshua Tree Village Neighbors attorney Babak Naficy also argued that the earlier hydrology study did not properly account for wastewater facilities. Nearby resident David Dodge disputed whether the revised analysis addressed wastewater odors and drainage adequately. These are the speakers' legal and environmental objections, not independently tested water contamination.
What the Board actually approved
The proposal, from Lovemore Investments, LLC, would divide approximately 18.49 acres at 61650 Alta Loma Drive into 64 home lots, a shared recreation parcel and a smaller common area for wastewater and drainage infrastructure. The Board initially approved the project in April 2025. In June 2026, Superior Court Judge Jeffrey Erickson found deficiencies in the county's environmental review concerning water-board consultation and stormwater analysis and directed that approvals be set aside.
On November 3 the Board rescinded the earlier approval and voted 4–1 to approve the proposal again using revised study materials. Supervisor Paul Cook dissented. The court was expected to revisit whether the county had complied with the earlier order at a December 2 hearing. A subsequent court determination or appeal could change the project's status.
Developer and county staff disagree with opponents
Applicant Axel Cramer told the supervisors that the county had corrected the two procedural issues identified by the court and that the proposal remained substantially unchanged. County planning staff said the wastewater treatment system would still require the regional water board's own permitting and that final engineering details could be resolved later. The regional board's October 9 letter said it could not decide on a discharge permit until a complete application was filed. The county's land-use vote is not a state discharge permit.
Why traffic and fire evacuation also came up
Speakers raised concerns about vehicles around Alta Loma Drive, Sunset Road, nearby school routes and traffic heading into Joshua Tree National Park. The county acknowledged ongoing traffic questions while treating separate road engineering measures as future matters. No new road improvement should be described as already funded or constructed merely because a supervisor offered to pursue it.
Watch the original government recording
The following is the county's full November 3 Board of Supervisors meeting; select Agenda Item 57 — Lovemore Ranch in the recording navigation to hear testimony and the final vote.
Open the county's original recording directly if playback is blocked.
San Bernardino County Board of Supervisors, November 3, 2026 — official video, agenda Item 57. This is a county recording; California58 has not edited or rehosted it. The Desert Trumpet's November 8 report explains the documentary disputes and quotes the testimony. Original environmental files and any court ruling remain necessary for a final outcome.
What we still need to know
Has the regional water board received a complete discharge-permit application? Can the detention basin and wastewater works legally and physically fit on the same parcel? What enforceable traffic and stormwater conditions will apply? How will existing neighbors know if a later judicial ruling changes the entitlement? These are precise records questions, not evidence that a contamination event has occurred.
Editorial transparency: California58 reports attributable public testimony and agency records. It has not independently interviewed speakers, sampled groundwater, verified future court outcomes or inspected the property.
Support Joshua Tree News
Choose how to support Joshua Tree News:
Credit / Debit Card via StripeChoose your contribution amount on the secure California58 Stripe checkout. One-time support for independent local journalism.
Continue with PayPal Continue with ZelleZelle payments go to Vitaly Ataev Troshin. Please verify the recipient in your bank before sending. Availability depends on your bank.
Optional reader support. When possible, add “Joshua Tree News” to the payment note. Contributions are not advertised as tax-deductible. Support does not influence editorial decisions.More from Joshua Tree News
- Joshua Tree Desert View Trails Receive $1.98 Million Construction Contract; New Trails Not Planned →
- Joshua Tree Schools: Bond and Piñeiro Lead Separate Morongo Unified Trustee Races →
- Joshua Tree Parks Get $3.1 Million Construction Contract for Playgrounds, Trails and Pump Track →
- Joshua Tree Vacation Rentals 2026: Permit Map and the Correct 24/7 Complaint Hotline →
- Joshua Tree News: Covington Flats Closed for July 4 Weekend in 2026 to Reduce Human-Caused Wildfire Risk →
COMMUNITY
Comments
Join the California58 conversation. You must be signed in to comment.
Create a free California58 account or sign in with an available social provider.